Chapter 7 - The Currency of Approval
The following three days revealed the true architecture of Graham’s family.
On Tuesday afternoon, Walter’s sister, Aunt Muriel—a woman who lived in an apartment near High Park and had spent thirty years not speaking to Brenda over an inherited silver tea service—called my mobile phone.
"Margo, dear," Muriel said, her voice crackling with the dry, ancient gossip of Toronto’s old Protestant establishment. "I hear there was quite a performance on Thursday. Brenda called our cousin Jean in Victoria before the dishes were even cleared. Did you really take the bird off the sideboard?"
"I took it off the counter before it was carved, Aunt Muriel," I said, sitting in my parked car outside Theo’s daycare.
Muriel let out a dry, rattling cackle that sounded like dry leaves scraping over concrete. "Good for you. That woman has been telling people her oven is broken for fifteen years whenever she doesn't want to spend the morning basting. She used to make Graham's grandmother bring the ham from Oakville every Easter, then complain the glaze was too sticky for her crystal platters. Don't you dare apologize, Margo. If you give that woman an inch, she’ll measure it with a surveyor's chain and bill you for the gravel."
Muriel’s call was amusing, but the subsequent interactions were not.
Graham did not return home Tuesday night until nearly eleven. When he came into the bedroom, smelling of cold air and restaurant pasta, he dropped a thick manila folder on my side of the bed.
"What is this?" I asked, looking up from my book.
"Renee went over the deeds," he said, his voice flat, completely drained of the previous week’s theatrical rage. He looked exhausted, the skin beneath his eyes bruised with dark circles. "The house in Leaside. The mortgage is in both our names, but my grandmother’s trust provided thirty-five percent of the initial equity for the down payment. Renee says if we were to proceed with any kind of... separation, that equity would be contested as an excluded gift rather than a matrimonial asset."
I stared at the manila folder. The label was written in Renee’s sharp, slanted legal handwriting: Hendrick / Property Distribution Analysis.
"You had your sister draft a division of assets because I took a Thanksgiving turkey to my mother’s?" I asked, my voice barely above a whisper.
"I had my sister explain to me what my options are if my wife decides she wants to hold our marriage hostage over a family disagreement!" Graham snapped, though he looked away as he said it, his gaze fixing on the floorboards near the closet. "You threatened me on Sunday, Margo. You told me I couldn't take my son to see his grandparents without a lawyer. What was I supposed to do? Sit here and wait for you to serve me with papers?"
I looked at him—really looked at him.
I saw the boy who had grown up in that big brick house with the wraparound porch, surrounded by parents who used approval as a variable interest rate. If Graham got straight A’s, Brenda displayed his report card on the hall table; if he brought home a B-plus in geometry, Walter forgot to attend his hockey games for three weeks. If Renee made partner at thirty-two, she was given the grandmother’s sapphire ring; if Graham chose civil engineering over corporate law, his father introduced him at the club as "my son who likes to build things with his hands."
He had spent thirty-six years running on an emotional treadmill, terrified of being dropped from the Hendrick registry of merit. And now, because I had refused to join him on that treadmill, he was reaching for the only tools his family understood: legal threats, financial leverage, and emotional eviction.
"Do you love me, Graham?" I asked.
The question caught him entirely off guard. His mouth opened slightly, then closed. He looked at the folder on the bed, then back at my face.
"Of course I love you," he muttered defensively. "What kind of question is that? I work for this family. Everything I do is for this house, for you, for Theo."
"No," I said softly, shaking my head. "Everything you do is for Brenda’s opinion of you. You don't work for this house, Graham. You work to prove to Walter that you didn't make a mistake by marrying an occupational therapist whose mother lives in a duplex on the Danforth. You let your sister audit our marriage because you're terrified that if you stand up to your mother, she’ll look at you the way she looked at me on Thursday."
"That isn't true," he whispered, but his fingers were twitching at his sides.
May you like
"It is true," I said, picking up Renee’s folder without opening it and setting it on the bedside table. "And the most tragic thing about it, Graham, is that she will never give you what you're sweating for. If you divorce me, if you take Theo to her house every single Sunday for the next twenty years, she will still find something wrong with the way you live your life. She will tell you your second wife’s hair is too long, or your promotion came too late, or your son doesn't speak to his elders with enough deference. Because Brenda Hendrick doesn't want peace. She wants jurisdiction."
Graham didn't answer. He turned off the bedside lamp on his side of the room, lay down on top of the covers with his clothes still on, and stared at the dark ceiling until the house grew cold.
